Columbia University in the City of New York

Harriman Institute's

Latest News
Marshall D. Shulman
November 20, 2026

The following remarks in celebration of Marshall D. Shulman were delivered on December 9, 1986 at a dinner planned in his honor. To celebrate Shulman’s legacy for Harriman’s 80th Anniversary, these remarks are being made available online for the first time. The full tribute contains additional texts by Alfred Stepan (Former Dean of Columbia’s School of International and Public Affairs), Cyrus R. Vance (Former U.S. Secretary of State) Michael Sovern (Former President of Columbia University), Pamela C. Harriman – along with a response by Marshall D. Shulman himself.

 

Seweryn Bialer’s Tribute to Shulman

It is a privilege to be Marshall’s colleague and friend in the Department of Political Science at Columbia, the Russian Institute, and now in the Harriman Institute. […]

I would like to stress especially two of his major contributions to the field of Soviet studies. First, he brought to the study of Soviet foreign policy, more than anyone else, a key ingredient, an ingredient that Max Weber considered necessary in the study of distant or alien societies, namely, empathy—an ability to understand the way of thinking of people of different cultures, even when one does not sympathize with their thinking. Marshall’s contribution to our understanding of how the Soviets think, and how their thinking changes, is immense. Secondly, Marshall is probably the first, or one of the first, who brought to the field of arms control a many-sided knowledge of the Soviet Union. This is still very rare today, though many do follow in Marshall’s footsteps.

As a colleague and a teacher, Marshall is an enemy of orthodoxy, and always encourages diversity of views. He is a catalyst in bringing together formally and informally disparate elements of the study of the Soviet Union and diverse people toward the common goal of greater knowledge and greater understanding. As a colleague and a friend, Marshall is loyal. He is a man of great personal integrity, and a man of kindness, of understanding, and of compassion. […]

 

Robert Legvold’s Tribute to Shulman

[…] Years ago—in fact, not so long after I finished studying with Marshall—someone who is at the other end of the political spectrum from him said of me and another of Marshall’s students: “Legvold and X are not such bad folks, but the problem is they have been Shulmanized.” Apart from the odd rather automotive image this evokes for me, the criticism is not wrong. I suspect many of us have been Shulmanized. Not because that was his purpose, but because that was his effect. […] Marshall affected us so because he came closest to what Bronson Alcott once said about good teaching: “The true teacher defends his pupils against his own personal influence. He inspires self-distrust. He guides their eyes from himself to the spirit that quickens him. He will have no disciple.”

And the spirit that quickened him, the spirit that he shared with us—no, that he imposed on us—was a deep dissatisfaction with simple, settled, self-satisfied approaches to the Soviet question. It was never so much what we thought, as much as it was how casually and thoughtlessly we got there—and then, almost as bad, how gracelessly and incompetently we committed our thoughts to paper or print. He has cared. He has cared about our level of understanding and what we were prepared to do about it, as he has cared about the level of understanding within this country.

Jean Monnet liked to quote a diplomat who said: “The world is divided into those who want to become someone, and those who want to accomplish something.” Monnet preferred to belong to the second category, because, he mused, “There is less competition.” So it is with Marshall. A lot of you know that, but I think it is his students who know it best, because we are the beneficiaries, particularly those who now come after us at the Institute that he built. But we also know so well because we have felt most palpably his standards and his hopes. […]

 

logo